Archive for June 3rd, 2008

Quick post-mortem

John McCain: Bob Dole without the charisma, and with a scary death-rictus grin and weird Batman-villain giggle.

Hillary Clinton: this really could have, should have been her moment. Before she came on, my wife and I were talking about the possibility of an Obama/Clinton ticket, moving beyond the unpleasantness of the primary to bring the Democratic party together, acknowledging that she has earned many votes, and deserves respect for that. And if Hillary had come out and graciously conceded, we might have been able to sustain that fantasy. Instead, she gave an utterly tone-deaf speech which was All About Her, and at the end of it, I was ready personally to throw her under a bus, should one be passing by.

Barack Obama: Pitch perfect speech in front of a rock star crowd, the clear winner of the evening in every respect.

posted by Tom Tomorrow at 10:55 PM | link
Un-Poisoning The Well

With the superdelegate endorsements coming in fast, it’s looking like even a lackluster showing tonight in Montana and South Dakota will be enough to push Obama over the delegate threshold. All eyes now seem to be on Hillary Clinton. I don’t know if she’ll concede or not, but it would be nice if she at least started the process of unifying the party by cutting out all of her bullshit rhetoric that’s had the effect of subtly implying that Barack Obama’s victory is somehow illegitimate.

Hasn’t that been the whole point of Clinton’s campaign over the past few months? There was the insistence that caucuses are “undemocratic” and that Obama’s wins were in small states that “don’t count” and the insistence that Obama was trying to “disenfranchise” voters in Florida and Michigan and finally their long-standing obsession with the popular vote. The clear impression here is that Barack Obama may have technically won the nomination, but that Hillary Clinton is the true choice of the American people.

Which is a load of crap. If caucuses didn’t count, the Obama campaign would have diverted their organizational energy into other contests. If the small states didn’t count, they would have concentrated their resources in large states like Clinton did. If Michigan counted, Obama wouldn’t have removed his name from the ballot like many of his fellow candidates. And if the popular vote was the metric by which the Democratic party chose its nominee, both candidates would have completely ignored sparsely populated states (like SD & MT). Obama’s campaign has been about accruing delegates wherever he can get them, not winning the race according to some hypothetical rules that come out of the Clinton campaign.

By insisting that there’s something unfair about the way the Democratic party is choosing its nominee, Clinton has undermined Obama’s victory and has done more to weaken the party going into the convention than McCain could dream of. While I happen to agree with many of the points the Clintons make (caucuses are undemocratic, popular vote better metric than delegates), the relative unfairness of these particular points is trumped by something that’s even more unfair, changing the rules mid-game. In order to make her case to undeclared superdelegates, Clinton has exploited some of the legitimate grievances that some have about the nominating process (grievances that she only seems to have found religion on when their outcomes prove to be politically expedient), and in the process has fanned the flames of division within her party.

So if Hillary is truly serious about bringing the party together, it’s not enough to simply concede the race, but to reiterate to her supporters that the Democratic nomination is decided by delegate count alone and, more importantly, that Barack Obama won a fair fight to gain the nomination. In other words, she needs to have the humility to put her party ahead of her own ambitions.

posted by Greg Saunders at 7:58 PM | link
May 2008
S M T W T F S
« Apr  
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031
June 2008
S M T W T F S
 
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930  
July 2008
S M T W T F S
  Aug »
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  
Winters Web Works
extreme trackingSite Meter
Login